The abuse of illegal drugs ought to be treated as a matter of public health, not of criminal justice.
Pro "…the solution lies in prevention, which in turn is largely a matter of education and enforcement, which aims at keeping drug pushers away from children and teenagers. The abuse of illegal drugs ought to be treated as a matter of public health, not of criminal justice.
The Southcentral foundation http: Often involves issues such as water safety, sanitation, immunizations, housing, infectious diseases and illness prevention. Societal Welfare The resolution frames the area of concern in the round, which is societal welfare.
This is because society suffers when its members have poor health outcomes, such as the negative consequences associated with drug use. Consequentialism Consequentialism is defined by the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy as "whether an act is morally right depends only on consequences.
The resolution frames the area of concern for the round, being that of looking at the consequences, positive or negative, of both the criminal justice system and the public health approach when deciding how to treat the matter of abuse of illegal drugs.
Thus, we default to the Criterion of consequentialism, because we must look at the harms and benefits associated with these two systems.
The resolution does not imply any specific actor because the resolution is used in a passive voice. In any statement using a passive voice, the subject receives the action. This means the Affirmative is not shackled by the massive burden of defending a specific actor.
The public health approach prevents harmful consequences by preventing drug abuse. The public health approach uses preventative measures to control and mitigate drug use. Findings have revealed the myriad contributors to addiction… research strives to identify the factors that put people at risk of drug abuse or protect them from it.
Results lead to more effective strategies to prevent people from ever using drugs in the first place. This highlights the… plan to continue to support… the most effective HIV risk-reduction interventions for different populations… This includes seeking out the best ways to incorporate HIV education, testing, counseling, and referral and supporting research to identify and overcome stigma and HIV and drug abuse.
NIDA also sponsors research to learn more about the multiple interactions that occur with neurological complications of HIV, substance abuse, other comorbid disorders.
This knowledge can inform the development of more responsive interventions. The public health approach targets the underlying causes of drug use with preventative measures. The criminal justice system just covers up the problem of criminal behavior, without actually fixing it.
Increased rates of incarceration only leads to a vicious, vacuous circle of committing crimes. The criminal justice system ignores the factors that account for recidivism.
Occurrence and severity of recidivism were measured by self-report and official criminal records. Cluster analyses revealed that highest recidivism rates were found in a type with a high amount of risk factors, a low amount of protective factors… The least severe recidivists were characterized by low amounts of risk, high amounts of protective factors… Regression analysis reveals that occurrence of self-report recidivism is strongly predicted by… the amount of risk factors.
Increased rates of incarceration leads to overcrowding in prisons. In the comments section, my opponent agreed to debate me about whether or not drugs should be legalized. My position is that the production, sale, possession, and use of illegal recreational drugs should be legal for adults.
I will not be responding to the points my opponent made in the first round because they could be used to support both of our positions.
If drugs were legal, gangs in US inner cities would lose their main source of revenue. Latin American drug cartels currently killing tens of thousands and destabilizing governments would lose their source of income and dissolve.
The Taliban and other terrorist groups would lose their main source of income. But what about increased drug use?
In fact, crime among drug users would probably decrease. There would be an increase in drug users, yes. But where would these new drug users come from? The new users would have to come from the group of people that respected the law too much to use drugs while they were illegal.
Those people are unlikely to become criminals. In addition, alcohol Not meth, not PCP, not heroin, not crack—just alcohol is the only drug that has been shown to cause aggression.
But what about addicts stealing to support their habit? If drugs were legalized, the price would fall to a small fraction of the black market price. Not only does strong law enforcement cause crime, it also often hurts law-abiding people.Resolved: The abuse of illegal drugs ought to be treated as a matter of public health, not of criminal justice.
Lindsay Van Luvanee Idaho State University The abuse of illegal drugs has been a contentious issue, both in the United States and around the world, since the mid s. Oct 01, · "ought to be treated as a matter of public health, not of criminal justice". If the affirmative were trying to prove this true, would they simply have to argue for public health, or does the wording imply that the affirmative argue as to why it should be public health and not be criminal justice.
Oct 01, · The NFL Lincoln Douglas debate resolution for November / December has been released: Resolved: The abuse of illegal drugs ought to be treated as a matter of public health, . The abuse of illegal drugs ought to be treated as a matter of public health, not of crimial justice.
Drugs & the Brain Wallet Card: This tool is designed for people leaving criminal justice facilities and transitioning back to a less structured environment. To prepare these people to return to their home environment, counselors can customize this tool to help identify triggers that could prompt a drug relapse.
I Affirm the Resolution “Resolved: The abuse of illegal drugs ought to be treated as a matter of public health, not of criminal justice.”. The definitions I uphold are. Abuse: Using something habitually, according to Stedman’s Medical rutadeltambor.com means that abuse as stated in the resolution includes only the actual use of drugs, not violence or trafficking related to them.